Call Us Today


Schedule A Consultation

Contact Us Today

Live Chat
Speak with a licensed Medicare professional today.

Which is the Best Medicare Supplement for Me?

Finding the best Medicare supplement plan for you is far more simple than you might think. Want the secret to choosing the perfect Medicare supplement plan for you?

I’m here to help you with that.

Many times when a person is new to Medicare, he or she feels overwhelmed by all the choices. They fear to make a wrong decision. Not to worry!

I can eliminate this fear by walking you through a series of simple questions you can ask yourself. These questions will help lead you to the best Medicare supplement plan for you.

First, though, let’s point out that Medicare supplements and Medicare Advantage plans work differently. In this article, we’ll be concentrating on Medicare supplement plans, which in my book get 5 stars for a variety of reasons.

If you are unsure of the difference between Medicare supplements and Medicare Advantage plans, read this post first and then return to this page. Then we’ll use these questions to narrow down to the best Medicare supplement for you.

Which Medicare plans does your doctor take?

In my experience, the best Medicare supplement coverage for you is usually one that you know your doctors will accept. Most people don’t want to part with their trust providers.

Fortunately, this is pretty easy with Medicare supplements because as long as your doctor accepts Original Medicare, he will accept any Medicare supplement. It doesn’t matter if that is an Aetna Medicare supplement or a Blue Cross Blue Shield Medicare supplement or a Kmart Special Medicare supplement.

Clearly I’m kidding on that last one, but I hope you get the point.

The chances that your doctor accepts Original Medicare are very good. There are over 800,000 providers on Medicare’ network. The Kaiser Family foundation reported in 2015 that more than 9 in 10 primary care physicians accept Medicare. You can use Medicare supplement coverage anywhere around the nation without referrals.

A quick phone call to your doctor’s office can help you confirm that a Medicare supplement (as opposed to a Medicare Advantage plan) would work for you.

Simply ask: Does Dr. Smith accept Medicare? Most of the time you will hear yes.

Sometimes you might find a doctor whose practice is full. It’s not that he doesn’t like your Medicare supplement. It’s that he has too many Medicare patients. I have found that if you’ve been treating with a doctor prior to age 65, he will usually continue to see you once you transition to Medicare as your primary insurance.

An Important Distinction Between Medicare Plans

The best Medicare supplement or Advantage plan is always one that will allow you see your favorite doctors.

If you are still trying to decide between Medicare supplements and Medicare Advantage plans, you can also ask whether the doctor participates in any Medicare Advantage plans, and get a list of those plans.

However here’s a critical point: verify what you find out by checking each Medicare plan’s provider directory. Ensure that the directory shows that doctor in the network. Cross-referencing this information against the plan directory is so important.

All too often we have people contact our agency after they tried to do this on their own. Inevitably they find out too late that the person in the doctor’s office gave them incorrect information.

Which Companies Get the Best Medicare Supplement Reviews?

Often our clients ask us who offers the best Medicare supplement plans in terms of financial ratings or customer service. This can vary based on the state you live in and the plan you are researching.

In general, I give all Medicare supplements an A+ when it comes to claims payment. You can read more about my opinion on this in my blog post called Medicare Plan F Reviews.

When it comes to customer service though, your best bet is to enroll through a broker like us. That way when you have a problem, you can call and speak with your agent directly instead of calling some big insurance company call center.

A really good Medicare insurance broker will have a Client Service Team in place to handle back-end services for you. This might include helping you with Medicare appeals if something gets denied, conferencing in your pharmacy if there is an issue with getting a prescription filled. These are things that the Medicare supplement company definitely will NOT do for you.

Your own agent or broker will always be more helpful than a nameless, faceless customer service representative at your insurance carrier.

We work with all the top Medicare supplement plans in every market. We can tell you which of those makes the most sense for you based on the data we have.

What is your Risk Tolerance?

Our agency often works with clients who helped their aging parents through a few illnesses. On such client, Sue told me that her mother had battled lymphoma for many years and went through several rounds of chemotherapy.

She was astonished at the size of the medical bills they received and even further astonished to find that her mother’s Medicare supplement had covered every dime. Because of this, she knew she wanted the same kind of coverage.

What Sue said was “If I am sick, I want to be able to concentrate on getting well. I don’t want to be worrying about how many bills are accumulating in my mailbox.”

So for this client, the natural choice was a Medicare supplement Plan F, which has very predictable benefits and covers comprehensively. With Plan F, Sue would have nothing out of pocket at the doctor’s office or hospital.

On the other hand, if Sue preferred a lower monthly premium in exchange for her covering some of her own deductibles and copays, then the best Medicare Supplement might be a Plan N.  There are 10 different standardized Medicare supplement plans to choose from. You can find one that covers enough for your comfort and peace of mind.

So ask yourself how much risk tolerance you have, and that should lead you toward one choice or another. This is the way we identify the best Medicare supplement plans for our clients here.

And that leads us to the third question regarding the best Medicare supplement plans, which is:

Which is the Best Medicare Supplemental Insurance for Your Budget?

Your budget is a consideration in identifying the best Medicare supplement plan for you.

Living on a fixed income is harder than most people think. You are still subject to inflation like everyone else, but the money you have coming in from Social Security and your investments has to last you for the rest of your life. Sometimes this single factor will make the decision for you.

For a person turning 65 in Texas, you might expect to pay around $150/month for a Medicare supplement Plan F. It varies by zip code, gender, and age, but let’s use this number as an example. If your budget includes $1800/year for medical insurance, then a Medicare supplement Plan F provides great coverage.

If spending $1800/year leaves you with very little for life’s other expenses, you might be more comfortable with a Plan G or Plan N or even a High-Deductible Plan F.

You can read more of my tips for saving money on Medigap in this Forbes article.

Get the Best Medicare Supplement for YOU

These are the things we discuss with our own clients when helping them determine the best Medicare supplement plans for them. An insurance agency like Boomer Benefits can help you answer these questions and then find the best Medigap plans that meet YOUR needs based on your answers.

If you enjoyed this blog post and learned from it, give us a try so that you can experience all the great back-end policy service that you’ll get. This includes free claims support and assistance with evaluating which Part D drug plan offers your medications. We also provide annual rate comparisons to ensure you stay with the most cost-effective policy in your area. Find out who the top Medicare supplement plans in your area are today.

The best Medicare supplement for you is out there! Get in touch with us for help finding it today.

Schedule A Consultation

It can be difficult to know whether or not you have proper coverage, but we can help!

Any questions? Feel free to give us a call.



Medicare Alone Is Not Enough

Compare Medicare Plans Now!

TCPA Consent & Privacy

The Benefit Link, a Licensed Insurance Agency with its physical office in Texas, employs insurance agents (producers), and through such agents, can provide these services to clients in all 50 States of the USA. By clicking on a form, you authorize The Benefit Link to call you and send pre-recorded messages, text messages, and in-app Facebook messages to you about The Benefit Link products and services at the telephone number you have on file with Facebook, or any other telephone number or contact information that you provide to The Benefit Link, including your mobile phone if provided, using an automated dialer and email, even you are on the national or state “Do not Call” list. You understand that your consent is not a requirement to purchase products and services from The Benefit Link. Message and data rates may apply, and you can opt-out anytime.